DING Yaopeng1, SHEN Jiangping1, 2
2026, 40(1): 121-133.
L-historisme matérialiste is the subjective definition of historical materialism as a subordinate theory of “historicism” by scholars of “historicism”The emergence of lhistorisme matérialiste is based on the ideological motivation of historicist theorists to reflect on the inherent flaws of historicism, and it distinguishes itself from the mainstream understanding of historicism with distinct realistic and materialist characteristicsHowever, lhistorisme matérialiste is confined by its own historicist principlesBehind the onesided emphasis on the historical characteristics of historical materialism lies a series of deconstructive and narrow definitions of historical materialism, including historical economicism as a variant of economic determinism, the binary structure of the combination of human natural nature and historicism, the negative understanding of the dominant position of human beings, and the historical socialism that denies practical attributes and revolutionary characteristicsThe criticism of lhistorisme matérialiste enlightens us to reexamine the ideological connection between historical materialism and historicismIn the traditional determination of the relationship between the two, namely the identity theory, the divergence theory, and the inheritance transcendence theory, the divergence theory is relatively correct, but it fails to condense the understandingIn fact, the transcendence of historical materialism over historicism lies in replacing the historical ontology of the conceptualized history with material production, replacing the historical teleology theory of the subject of imagination with the historical subject theory emphasizing peoples role in creation, replacing the theory of historical irregularity with dialectics in the social and historical structure, and replacing the special thinking method with the dialectical unity of universality and particularity.